That's a tough call Packer.  Do you think they will be able to tell this year if they missed on both guys? They are both young and maybe one of them really steps up and becomes the next Marty Turco. I know that's a long shot, but a bad Freshman year isn't always the end all.  If neither one gets much time the rest of the season, I think they are still an incomplete.

But, I know what your saying you have to make a decision and maybe try again with another goalie.