I am really on the fence about just puttiing Rutledge in net, just because he's the scholie goalie. I know no one has shown much in net, but Rutledge has had his shot and done nothing, why do we think all of a sudden he's going to start playing better?
I guess this season is pretty much done and you have to turn your attention to next year. Let all three goalies know they are basically playing for the right to start in the playoffs and be #1 going into next year. Just keep rotating the three for the rest of the year and grade them out. One who plays the best starts the playoffs and plays as long as they are doing a good job. As long as he plays well he starts next season as #1.
I know we don't like to run people off, but let's be honest. This is big time D-I hockey, if a kid can't cut it he should probably go somewhere else to play and it should be told to hm. Let the three know that who ever seems to be bringing up the rear in competiton will probably not be invited back next season and we'll be looking for another goalie to take their place on the roster. If nothing else you see what these kids can do with a fire under their butt and how they respond to pressure.